• August 17, 2025 |
  • News

Hamilton Man Accused in $95 Million Ponzi Scheme

A Hamilton man, a trusted pillar of his community, is accused of orchestrating a nearly $95 million Ponzi scheme that defrauded almost a thousand people and organizations. Miles “Burt” Marshall allegedly used his local reputation to lure investors with an “8% Fund,” leaving many with devastated life savings.

by Jack Smith |
SHARE
Elderly couple smiling, standing outdoors with a lake, trees, and tables in the background.

In the quiet, picturesque folds of upstate New York, where Colgate University casts its academic shadow over the charming village of Hamilton, a profound sense of betrayal now hangs heavy in the air.

For decades, Miles “Burt” Marshall was not just a name; he was an institution, a bedrock of financial advice and seemingly unwavering reliability.

He was the man you went to see, the trusted neighbor who would handle your nest egg, the local sage promising growth faster than any bank.

But the edifice of trust he so meticulously constructed has crumbled, revealing a devastating void of nearly $95 million, owed to almost a thousand people and organizations in what authorities now allege was a sprawling Ponzi scheme.

Marshall, a 73-year-old businessman, cultivated an image of folksy competence and deep community roots.

Operating from a well-appointed office just down the road from the university, he offered an array of services: tax preparation, insurance sales, property rentals, even a print shop.

His family name carried weight, inherited from parents who ran a respected local insurance and realty business.

To many, Marshall embodied the very essence of small-town reliability – a man whose prosperity seemed to reflect his acumen, reinforcing the belief that he could certainly make your money grow too.

The cornerstone of his alleged scheme was the so-called “8% Fund.”

Marshall promised a guaranteed 8% annual interest, an enticing figure in an era of fluctuating and often meager returns from traditional banks.

He claimed to invest the money locally, primarily in rental properties.

Clients received simple promissory notes, slips of paper that seemed to formalize a handshake deal, and could withdraw their funds with 30 days’ notice.

For years, Marshall made good on these promises, a performance that served as the most powerful form of marketing.

Word spread like wildfire through families, friend circles, and community groups.

“He would tell you about all the other people that invest. Churches invest. Fire companies invest. Doctors invest,” recalled Christine Corrigan, a client who, along with her husband, lost an estimated $1.5 million.

“So you’d think, ‘Well, they’re smart people. They wouldn’t be doing this if it wasn’t okay to do … Why are you going to be the suspicious one?’”

This psychological leverage was Marshall’s true genius.

He wasn’t just a financial advisor; he was a community pillar.

He hosted annual parties for his clients, remembered their birthdays, and gave away quaint gift bags filled with local maple syrup and honey, adorned with charming, self-deprecating slogans like, “Don’t be a sap. For proper insurance coverage call Miles B. Marshall.”

These were not mere pleasantries; they were meticulously crafted elements of a persona designed to disarm, to engender a level of trust that bypassed critical scrutiny.

In a close-knit community, questioning Burt Marshall felt akin to questioning a favorite uncle.

The promise of 8% interest, while unremarkable in the high-interest rate environment of the 1980s when Marshall began taking money, became increasingly anomalous as rates plummeted in subsequent decades.

Yet, the payments continued, fueling the illusion of success and drawing in more unsuspecting investors.

Dennis Sullivan, who lost around $40,000, recounted how the scheme snowballed through his family: his parents invested, then he did, then his fiancée, her daughter, his son, and even his snowmobile club.

“Everybody gets snowballed into it,” Sullivan lamented, a poignant testament to the insidious power of peer trust in a small community.

The illusion shattered in April 2023.

Marshall filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, declaring a staggering $90 million in liabilities against a mere $21.5 million in assets, mostly real estate.

He attributed the collapse to a “serious heart condition” requiring two surgeries, which reportedly cost him $600,000 and triggered a run on his notes as news of his illness spread.

But the bankruptcy trustee, Fred Stevens, painted a far grimmer picture, alleging Marshall’s insolvency was due to incompetent business practices and borrowing at above-market rates.

Crucially, the trustee contended that by 2011, Marshall was already engaged in the classic Ponzi maneuver: using new investor money to pay off previous investors.

This summer, the curtain was fully drawn back.

Marshall was indicted on charges including grand larceny and securities fraud, accused of stealing more than $50 million.

Prosecutors allege he fabricated the profitability of his real estate ventures, had his staff create “transaction summaries” with bogus account balances, and funneled hundreds of thousands of investors’ dollars into his personal expenses, from airline travel and restaurant meals to groceries and even yoga studio memberships.

The folksy facade, it seems, hid a deep and calculated deception.

The ripple effects of this betrayal are profound and heartbreaking.

Unlike the abstract, faceless losses in a multi-billion-dollar scheme like Bernie Madoff’s, Marshall’s alleged fraud struck at the very heart of a community, devastating individuals who knew him personally, shared meals with him, and trusted him with their life savings.

Retirees lost their nest eggs, laborers their hard-earned security, and families their future plans.

Barbara Baltusnik, owed hundreds of thousands, now worries about paying medical bills.

Dennis Sullivan’s mother, having lost her investment, has had to move in with him.

In Epworth, Georgia, Carolyn Call, who learned of Marshall through an uncle in upstate New York, finds herself unable to afford trips or even small joys for her grandchildren, her hopes of augmenting Social Security payments dashed.

“I’m just able to pay my bills and keep going,” she said, her words echoing the quiet desperation of so many.

Marshall has pleaded not guilty, and bankruptcy proceedings continue, with his home and properties sold off.

Investors are expected to recoup a paltry 5.4 cents on the dollar from these asset sales, a bitter pill for those who entrusted him with their entire financial future.

Potential claims against financial institutions are being pursued, but for many, the damage is already done.

The question that haunts the victims, articulated so plainly by Dennis Sullivan, is a universal one: “Who do you trust?”

In Hamilton, New York, a town once defined by its quiet charm and neighborly bonds, that question now carries the crushing weight of a deep and enduring wound.

Home » Hamilton Man Accused in $95 Million Ponzi Scheme
© Hampton Global 2026.
Join our newsletter
Stay up to date on latest stories